Top 50 Manga June 2006

Using a mixture of Comic Book Resources and ICV2 articles, here is the compiled Top 50 Manga chart according to Diamond’s direct market sales in the US.
These are sales from the direct market only, e.g. Local Comic Shops, this chart isn’t the same as the weekly bookscan top ten listing which is complied by Neilsen and reflects sales in bookstores, e.g. Borders, Barnes & Noble.

There are two charts complied, Top 300 comics (i.e. Monthly floppy format) and Top 100 graphic novels (i.e. Trades, Paperbacks, Mangas). Recently there has also been a Top 50 Manga chart which takes the titles that made it into the Top 100 graphic novels and then rounds it out at 50. This is the chart that I publish here on Love Manga.
On to this months, as before the emphasised titles at the beginning are those that were in the Top 100 Graphic Novel chart, in the position column the parenthesis number is where they placed in that chart. Using ICV2’s article I also have the estimated quantities too, but as ICV2 does not run the Top 50 manga chart the numbers only last for those that made the Top 100 Graphic Novel chart.

(The rest of the Top 50 chart will be added when CBR publish theirs!)

Position Title Publisher Estimate
01(06) Megatokyo vol.04 DC/CMX 4385
02(15) Naruto vol.10 Viz Media 3222
03(21) Kingdom Hearts vol.04 Tokyopop 3046
04(28) Path Of The Assassin vol.01 Dark Horse 2717
05(30) Oh My Goddess vol.23 Dark Horse 2655
06(34) Battle Angel Alita Last Order vol.07 Viz Media 2334
07(38) Lady Snowblood vol.04 Dark Horse 2250
08(41) Chrono Crusade vol.08 ADV Manga 1997
09(43) Yellow vol.04 DMP 1928
10(49) Dears vol.07 Tokyopop 1775
11(51) Battle Club vol.02 Tokyopop 1760
12(52) Crying Freeman vol.02 Dark Horse 1752
13(54) Yoshitake Amano Fairies Dark Horse 1722
14(55) Bleach vol.13 Viz Media 1699
15(59) Tenjho Tenge vol.08 DC/CMX 1607
16(61) Rurouni Kenshin vol.27 Viz Media 1607
17(63) Jazz vol.02 DMP 1592
18(64) Our Kingdom vol.03 DMP 1561
19(66) La Esperanca vol.03 DMP 1531
20(70) Clan Of Nakagamis DMP 1462
21(73) Hot Gimmick vol.11 Viz Media 1400
22(79) Cannon God Exaxxion vol.05 Dark Horse 1240
23(83) Angel Sanctuary vol.14 Viz Media 1186
24(84) Hana Kimi vol.12 Viz Media 1178
25(91) Vagabond vol.21 Viz Media 1156
26(96) Nana vol.03 Viz Media 1087
27(97) Love Mode vol.03 Tokyopop 1087

I’m publishing this chart a little early, i.e. before Comicbook Resources has the full top 50 so currently it only goes to 27 as that was the total Manga which made Diamond’s top 100 Graphic Novel chart.

There is though an added bonus of doing this, and that is it gives a much more interesting snapshot of which titles are the most popular this month and more intriguingly a more unusual breakdown of the publishers present. It is quite well know that Tokyopop general can fill up the last half of the Top 50 manga chart which inflates their total titles present to at least half. But now with just the Top 100 titles currently listed the makeup is extremely different, so much so that Tokyopop is relegated down to 4th spot with just 4 of the 27 titles belonging to them. Viz Media non-surprisingly take 9 titles and thus has the greatest representation but both Dark horse with 6 and Digital Manga Publishing with 5 have a very good month.

DC/CMX must be rubbing their hands with glee with their successful release of Megatokyo as it takes the top manga slot and now I would think is set to become their biggest series in the direct market, taking over from the controversial Tenjho Tenge which has been a constant stalwart of the chart. In much the same way Cannon God Exaxxion from Dark Horse doesn’t appear to have suffered either from it’s little bout of internet editing conflab.

Just thinking about Megatokyo not giving Dark Horse their top spot anymore and with the ending of Samurai Executioner which has been an excellent seller in the direct market, what is their next big seller going to be? Well the first volume of Path of the Assassin which seems the obvious successor does well in fourth place and Crying Freeman is slowly creeping upwards as the second volumes makes #12. Should be interesting contest to see if either can emulate Samurai Executioner in later volumes.

I know I mentioned earlier that Tokyopop sat in 4th place in terms of titles present but this is sort of a misnomer really as the cause of their drop is in part due to this month being a Digital Manga Publishing month. Every couple of months DMP has a real glut of titles in the chart and it creates this result. This isn’t to take away from DMP, in fact it just goes to show the strength of their titles as each volume consistently places at least equal to its preceding volume. One exception to this has always been Yellow. now in to its 4th volume we see it places its highest yet in the Top 100 GN at #43, making it the 9th highest manga which I think is mightily impressive.

Oh and does anyone think that it should be Rurouni Kenshin vol.28, or is vol.27 really having a resurgence? ^.^

6 Responses to “Top 50 Manga June 2006”

  1. DavidPWelsh Says:

    I don’t know why, but I’m always surprised by how well yaoi and shonen-ai do in the Direct Market.

    David, I’m lazy, so I’m going to ask you: are Megatokyo’s numbers comparable to what they were when it was coming out through Dark Horse? Did the publicity around the move give it any kind of a bump?

  2. David Taylor Says:

    Agggh you cruel man, you know I cannot resist finding that out now!

    Okay Megatokyo volume 03 was released last February (about when I started actually) and it placed #1 in the Top 50 but #9 in the overall Top 100 GN chart at 4149 copies (est.) which is pretty much identical to how it has done this time around.

    That’s the direct market though, the real interest for me is how well it does in the bookstore. The whole thing about Dark Horse being good in LCS, but is it good in bookstores?
    Well Megatokyo vol.3 lasted 4 weeks in the top 10 (#3, #4, #4, #10) back in Febraury 2005 when it was released, now volume 04 is currently still in the top 10 according to bookscan. It debut at #7 and in the second week is at #8 so could one say that Dark Horse did better for Megatokyo in the bookstore then CMX currently is, or is the power of Naruto skewing all the figures at the moment?

    Yeah go BL/Yaoi/Shounen-ai hybrids. It was one of the reasons I felt compelled to highlight Yellow. It is definitely at odds with that manly man image the comic shop always tries to make us believe it has.

  3. DavidPWelsh Says:

    I sometimes wonder if the ability to pre-order isn’t part of the reason that category does so well in comic shops. If you can’t be certain that a given title is going to show up at a Barnes & Noble, maybe it’s just easier to guarantee that you’ll get it at your local comic shop?

  4. David Taylor Says:

    You may call me sad, but I had (honest I had too) to go through ICV2’s site to find out what happened to Megatokyo 1 and 2

    Volume 01 was released in February/March 2004 and placed both at #88 (est. 807 copies) and #72 (1184 copies)

    Volume 02 was release in January 2004 at placed at #9 (3295 copies)

    I can only assume that was a REALLY late release for volume 01. Either way sales have improved on this title.

    I sometimes wonder if the ability to pre-order isn’t part of the reason…
    Then their is the whole pull-list and collectors mentality which just adds to it even more.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.